I found this site looking for feedback on an online vendor I was considering purchasing from. Said vendor would answer my calls, had no physical address list on their site, and according to the BBB may even be out of business.
However, according to webutation.com the vendor in question has a rating of 90/100 even though there had been zero reviews of said vendor.

I then tried their search option and searched for several sites that I know to be completely untrustworthy. I found that most of them had high positive ratings.

Its seems that webutation.com automatically gives every site in existence a 100% rating until someone submits a negative review. Even then the site's rating may not change.

Webutation.com honesty seems highly suspect.

Webutation ist eine gute Möglichkeit die Vertrauenswürdigkeit von Webseiten bzw. deren Betreiber zu eruieren.
Berücksichtigt werden unter Anderem Google Safe Browning, Norton Safeweb, Web of Trust, Jugendschutzeinstellungen und Wikipedia-Einträge.

If you post honest reviews, you may get Banned!!

I started using Webutation.net to post my reviews of Phishing and Scam websites. The same reviews that I post with SiteJabber, WOT, SiteAdvisor, Norton, AVG and Web Security Guard.

After reviewing several hundreds of sites I now receive the following message:

http://webutation.net/
Forbidden
You don't have permission to access / on this server.

Who knew that using a reputation/review site to warn other internet users about a Phishing/Scamming site would get you Banned on that review site!!

I am sorry to say something this harsh, but they hate mywot but use our service. What unthankful Copycats

Doesn't let you out by clicking "back".
Doesn't let you read reviews without taking a "quick survey".
Bears no relation to whether a site is trusted or not.

Do you REALLY need to know anything else??

Very unreliable website, site is useless.
Owner can delete comments they do not like on their scorecard.
They do not update correctly most of the time
Post a bad rating on webutation.net and it will be removed.
Funny as hell = http://www.webutation.net/go/review/mywot.com
You can also disagree/agree with a comment a couple of times
Source: https://www.mywot.com/forum/9082-wot-clone
I used to use this a lot, well I am not using it again.

untrusted.
open google you will see it green, then open it you will find it is yellow

Provides automated and human ratings of web domains with search. The web site loads quickly, the interface is convenient, and the information is concise.

Having said this, it appears that the data may be either somewhat manipulated or drawn from nonstandard sources. For example, webutation.net reports its Alexa rank as zero, whereas Alexa.com reports 9,232 as of the date of this comment. Paradoxically, it agrees with Alexa that Google's rank is 1.

This site permits impersonation and manipulation or other interference with ratings, not only by web site owners, but also by Webutation itself.

http://labs.sucuri.net/malware-data/webutation.net

webutation.net

Warning: Malicious Code Detected on This Website!

Infected with Malware

ISSUE DETECTED______DEFINITION________INFECTED URL
Website Malware _____MW:HTA:7**_____http://www.webutation.net/js/load_badge.js,malvertising,2015-07-15,1437003736

**Malware entry: MW:HTA:7
Definition: http://labs.sucuri.net/signatures/malware-entry-mwhta7
Description: This attack uses the .htaccess file to redirect users to a site serving malware (or spam). In some cases, the index.php is also modified to do the redirection as well.

Loads malware from: http://fgnfdfthrv.bee.pl/
alolipololi.osa.pl
gberbhjerfds.osa.pl
zxsoftpromo.ru
centralfederation.ru
chimeboom.ru
faqaboutme.ru
lkjoiban.ru
longqwality.ru
zxsoftpromo.ru
and other domains.

Affecting: Any type of web site (no specific target).

Also:

***** SiteCheck Issues Identified: URLs distributing the malware

======================================

http://www.urlvoid.com/scan/webutation.net/

Safety Scan Report

***** SCUMWARE ***** Alert
***** Quttera ***** Alert