Le site wikiislam.net est-il sûr ?

It's going to be contentious since it explicitly points out flaws in Islam. A good representation of the stuff you'd hear from conservatives Sunni Moulanas in Mosques (from my experience) but fortunately most muslims do not take Islam as literally as is described on the site. If you're a Muslim of strong religion you should be able to read this site and not have your faith shaken so take that as a challenge...

As a Muslim, i can tell you that this site is a despiteful source against Islam, working in a sneaky ways to defame Muslims and Islam, Do Not take anything from it unless you're want to convert your mind to be a racist one. And if my English is weak so here's another review i agree with: This site tries to portray itself as a neutral, secular look at Islam, but it definitely is anti-Islam propaganda masquerading like it's presenting fair and neutral information on the Islamic religion.

I don't know what so many people are pissed off by this website (it's likely that most of them are insecure believers). I just visited it to read the topic "Corruption of the Quran" and it doesn't use any opinion, nor it advocates hate or extremism. All I've seen so far is facts and links to quran and hadiths and some works of respected scholars.

This site is an Islamophobic site. Spreads completely false information about Quran, Islam and its prophet Muhammad (pbuh). The content of this site is full of lies, hate for islam and discrimination. This wiki promotes false information about islam. This is not an Islamic Wiki. This wiki is against Islam. This is an Anti Islamic wiki.

This site is made specifically to peddle intellectually bankrupt arguments against a religion. Its unorthodox opinions are often conveyed as fact instead of merely conjecture. The problem with sites like these is that they may cause fear and alienation for no good reason, and they might even motivate followers of the religion in question to behave in accordance with the information on the site.

This is nothing more than the rehashing of bigoted misconceptions that have been popular in the west for hundreds of years. Things are taken out of context, Muslim scholars aren't questioned or referred to, there is no real research but rather a reliance on the ignorance of ages past. There is nothing here but lies and bigotry.